Soil versus Hydro

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Puffin Afatty

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2007
Messages
2,565
Reaction score
4,150
Not to open a can of worms or anything, but which produces better, Soil grown plants or hydro grown plants??? consensus???:D by better, I mean more and tastier and potentcy-wise...
 
I was talking to the mod stoney yesterday about hydro. He told me the standard tomato in stores have 400 vitamin a i believe. His hydro tomatos have over 4000. Hydro is far better than soil for your plants because it maxes your plant out. I don't know much about hydro but that's what i've heard from Mr.Bud! ahaha.

~Burn One~
Dewayne
 
I've always heard that soil grows the best bud as far as taste and smell. May be a myth though.
 
Well i've had some great dro man, sweet, nice smelling, and very potent. But i've had the same with soil. I think it's very care-dependant. If you're good at hydro and know what you're doing, you can put a great kick into some buds. If you're good with soil you can do the same. Stoney just told me about how it maxes out the plants capability and about the 400 vit. a and his were 4000. Which that's an exponantial difference. So i don't really know, alls i know is either way if you do it right you'll get rewarding bud!!! :)

~Burn One~
Dewayne
 
I was explaining to dewayne about how regular soil grown tomatoes in the store have pretty close to 400 units of vitamin A per/pound. Hydro maters have 4,000 units per/pound.

That however is because of the amount of fertilizer that's used on the giant fields that the commercial growers have. The ferts translate into millions of dollars for these guys and they aren't putting any more on them than the law MAKES them put on them. The FDA requires that a pound of soil grown tomatoes have a minimum of 400 units of vitamin A, and that's what they calculate their ferts for.

With a MJ crop, soil growers tend to want to put as much ferts on them as they can. This causes the difference between growing characteristics to be more closely related.

I firmly believe that hydro weed grows faster, matures faster and flowers to completion faster. An 8 week flowering crop takes me 6 in hydro. It takes 8 weeks for a 10-12 week flowering plant in hydro.

The point being, hydro will provide the absolute maximum conditions for an MJ plant, where to do so with soil, you'd have to treat it like a hydro plant and let it get root bound in a perlite rich soil and feed it hydro nutes 4 times a day. Essentially, it's a hydro plant at that point.

When using only soil with soil type nutes, I believe that hydro will consistently outgrow soil.

I've proven this with many side by side grows.

As far as taste, and other criteria, I think the outcome is pretty much the same with the exception that hydro plants seem to me to have a much higher resin content when compared to soil grown.

Both are great. If it gets you to a 9 out of 10 in soil, and a 10 in hydro, will you be aware of the difference or be too stoned for it to matter?
 
hehe thanks for clarifying so i wasn't telling people what yous aid wrongly ahaha. Mr. Bud! ahaha. Well that seems really well put, i seen you opsting on threads and i knew you'd come to this one hehe.

~Burn One~
Dewayne
 
Stoney Bud said:
Both are great. If it gets you to a 9 out of 10 in soil, and a 10 in hydro, will you be aware of the difference or be too stoned for it to matter?

Touche
 
Give me a month or so and I can have your answer! I am flowering some from clones right now. Some in hydro and some in soil. I will tell you all after I try them each which is better. I can tell you this, my hydro girls are much thicker and fuller and smell much stronger! They are easily twice as big as my soil girls.
 
No point to really do it unless u just feel like doing it for the hell of it.... hydro Dropkicks soil in the face when it comes to quickness.
 
hey Kade... what I do is to take my best clones for my SOG and any others I plant in soil and put in 12/12 after a day or so. That's not to say they are weak clones. They are not, but when I take six cuttings for 3 plants and five of them take (or even six) I jsut can't throw out the others! So I have a spot in my SOG where I can put a couple 2-liter bottles with the extra clones. Started doing it in a passive hydro system now though (i.e. using perlite and not soil and just feeding them every day).
 

Latest posts

Back
Top