Sorry to hear about your order.
How can they replace your order? It's too expensive for them. They sell breeder packages for affordable prices so the risk I guess is when something goes wrong with your order then you can't do anything about it.
I couldn't disagree with that more. When a retailer charges EXTRA money for a guarantee, they are accepting money for assuming the risk that merchandise may not arrive safely, and that they will have to replace it. It's insurance. As far as it being too expensive: Again it's insurance. All the people that pay extra, and have no problems, thats how they make money. There is plenty you can do about it as well. You can hold their feet to the fire, and tell all you know about your experience. I personally have had all good experiences with Attitude, only 1 crushed seed out of many, and will continue to use them, however, I'll be damned if someone tells me "How can I replace your insured order? It's too expensive."