The FIRST thing you should do, before adding this or that, is make sure your pH testing is correct. You mention using "strips". What brand are they? IMO the only strips worth using are Macherey-Nagel - they cost about $12-$15 a box of 100. I've tried using cheaper strips and they are miles out. What read as 7 on the M-N strips read "somewhere around" 9 on the cheap strips.
If you've got M-N strips I would use them as the basis rather than the meter, until you verify the meter as accurate.
Use a known pH calibration solution and test that using an M-N strip and the meter. You should get the same reading. If not . . . it's the meter at fault.